Home › Journal › EN71 vs ASTM F963
EN71 vs ASTM F963: A Buyer's Compliance Guide
EN71 and ASTM F963 are the two toy safety standards that decide whether a crochet product can legally be sold in the European Union or the United States. EN71 is the European and UK-referenced test series; ASTM F963 is the mandatory federal toy safety standard in the United States. They test many of the same risks with different thresholds, so a single report cannot cover both markets.
For an importer, the practical question is rarely "what is the standard?" It is "which report do I need, who should it be issued to, and when in my timeline does it happen?" Compliance is a lead-time item, not paperwork you attach at the end. This guide sets out how the two standards differ, where crochet toys actually fail, and how to make sure the certificate on your listing is the one a marketplace or customs officer will accept.
What each standard is for
EN71 - the European and UK test series
EN71 is not one document but a series of parts applied according to the product:
- EN71-1 - mechanical and physical properties: small parts, sharp edges and points, attachment strength, packaging hazards.
- EN71-2 - flammability, including how quickly a toy material propagates a flame.
- EN71-3 - migration of specific elements such as lead, cadmium and mercury from toy materials, including dyed textiles and coatings.
A soft hand-crocheted toy is normally assessed under EN71-1 and EN71-2 as a minimum, with EN71-3 included where dyed yarn, printed labels or surface finishes are present. In the UK the same series appears in the UKCA marking route.
ASTM F963 - the United States standard
ASTM F963 is a single American standard covering mechanical and physical properties, flammability, and certain chemical limits for toys. It is mandatory for toys in the US market and operates alongside CPSIA rules on lead and phthalates. The structure is broader and flatter than EN71's numbered parts, and the thresholds and age-grading assumptions differ.
Where the two standards differ in practice
| Aspect | EN71 (EU/UK) | ASTM F963 (US) |
|---|---|---|
| Structure | Numbered parts (EN71-1/-2/-3), applied by product type | Single consolidated standard |
| Age grading | Age warnings and age-grade logic set in EN71-1 | Separate age-grading and use-of-safety rules in the US standard |
| Small parts | Small-parts cylinder and torque/tension testing | Similar logic with different force and duration parameters |
| Flammability | EN71-2 test method and classification | Its own flammability clauses |
| Chemical limits | EN71-3 element migration | Heavy elements plus CPSIA lead and phthalate limits |
| Marking | CE plus EN71 evidence; UKCA for the UK | Compliance with the US standard, no equivalent mark |
The table is deliberately at the level of test logic, not thresholds - thresholds change and should always be confirmed with an accredited laboratory against the current edition of each standard for your specific product.
Where crochet toys actually fail
Because the product is soft, the usual failure points are not the ones a plastic toy supplier worries about.
- Detachable safety eyes and attachments. A single eye or limb that pulls free, or produces a small part, fails both EN71-1 and ASTM F963. This is the most common cause of failure in amigurumi.
- Loose fibre and filling. If stuffing can be pulled out through the stitches, the toy fails on both mechanical integrity and, for some age grades, filling cleanliness.
- Yarn chemistry. Substantive dyes and finishes on cotton yarn drive EN71-3 results and, in the US, CPSIA chemical limits.
- Age-grade mismatch. A toy presented for children under 36 months is judged against the strictest small-parts rules. Getting the age grade wrong makes a compliant product non-compliant.
This is why a soft-toy programme should be engineered for the test from the first sample: attachments chosen so they can be force-tested, yarn traceable to OEKO-TEX Standard 100 certificates, and a pattern whose stitch tension holds filling reliably.
A compliance timeline that does not blow the schedule
| Step | When |
|---|---|
| Fix the age grade and target markets | Before design is finalised |
| Select yarn, eyes and fittings to the target standard | During pattern drafting |
| Approve a physical sample | 5-7 business days for a new design |
| Submit the sealed sample for testing | Immediately after sample approval - one to two weeks |
| Mass production | After the report is issued, 15-30 days |
The mistake to avoid is testing after production. If a test fails on a detail such as attachment force, the fix is a pattern and fitting change that invalidates the finished goods already made.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need both EN71 and ASTM F963?
Only if you sell in both markets. EN71 is the standard referenced for toys placed on the EU and UK markets, while ASTM F963 is the mandatory federal toy safety standard in the United States. A seller shipping to Europe and North America needs evidence against both, usually issued as separate reports from the same accredited laboratory.
What does EN71 cover?
EN71 is split into parts: EN71-1 covers mechanical and physical properties such as small parts, sharp edges and attachment strength; EN71-2 covers flammability; EN71-3 covers migration of specific elements from toy materials. Soft crochet toys are normally tested under EN71-1 and EN71-2 at minimum, with EN71-3 where dyed yarns and surface coatings are involved.
What does ASTM F963 cover?
ASTM F963 is a single US standard covering mechanical and physical properties, flammability, and heavy-element and phthalate content for toys. It uses similar test logic to EN71 but with different thresholds and age-grading rules, and in the United States it sits alongside CPSIA requirements such as lead and phthalate limits.
Are crochet toys treated differently from plastic toys?
The test principles are the same, but the failure points differ. Crochet toys are soft, so the primary risks are detachable safety eyes, loose fibre and dyed yarn chemistry rather than sharp edges or rigid small parts. That is why we pull-force test every eye and limb to a 90N standard, which exceeds the usual requirement, and source yarn traceable to OEKO-TEX Standard 100 certificates.
How should a safety report be worded for my order?
The report must name your product and your selling entity, not only the factory. It should state the standard and part numbers tested, the age grade applied, the laboratory's accreditation, and the sample description including yarn composition. A report issued to a different company or covering a different construction cannot be used to support your listing.
How long do compliance reports take, and do they need refreshing?
Physical testing of a crochet toy sample usually takes one to two weeks after the sample is finalised, so compliance should be scheduled alongside sampling rather than after it. Reports do not expire as such, but they only cover the design and materials tested - if you change yarn, dye supplier, eye fitting or pattern, the affected tests need to be repeated.
Get a compliance-ready sample
Send your target markets and age grade for a 24-hour quotation with testing built into the schedule. See also our OEKO-TEX certified cotton yarn, crochet baby toys & gift sets, and low-MOQ options for first orders.
Email bianhaitao@kivastitch.com · WhatsApp +86 186 3356 8777 · Alibaba haitao1688.en.alibaba.com